Hard Enamel Pins vs. Soft Enamel Pins: What’s the difference?

Enamel pins are a great avenue for self-expression and a way to showcase your personal interests. With their versatility and collectible nature, these tiny pieces of art have taken the world by storm. However, not all enamel pins are created equal. Two common types, hard enamel and soft enamel, differ in their production process and resulting quality. Today we'll delve into the differences between hard enamel pins and soft enamel pins, why hard enamel is considered higher quality, and when soft enamel pins might be a better choice.


Hard Enamel Pins:

Hard enamel pins, also known as cloisonné pins, are created using a meticulous process that involves several steps. The enamel is added in layers and then cured at high temperatures, resulting in a smooth, polished surface. This technique ensures a durable and long-lasting pin with a jewelry-like finish.

Hard enamel pins have distinct features:

  • Smooth, flat surface: Hard enamel pins have a smooth and level surface due to the polishing process, making them visually appealing and giving them a high-quality appearance.
  • Metal separation: Metal barriers separate the different enamel colors, giving a defined and precise look to the design.
  • Durability: Hard enamel pins are highly durable, resistant to scratches, and less prone to damage from everyday wear and tear.


Soft Enamel Pins:

Soft enamel pins, on the other hand, are created using a different technique. After the base metal is stamped with the design, the enamel colors are added to the recessed areas. The pins are then baked at lower temperatures, allowing the enamel to sink below the metal's surface, resulting in a textured finish.

Soft enamel pins possess the following characteristics:

  • Textured surface: Soft enamel pins have a slightly raised surface due to the recessed metal lines and the enamel sinking below them, creating a textured effect.
  • Color variation: The recessed areas create natural color variation and shading, giving the pin a three-dimensional appearance.
  • Cost-effective: Soft enamel pins are generally more affordable to produce, making them a popular choice for large quantities and budget-conscious projects.


Image source: https://www.stadriemblems.com/

Why Hard Enamel Pins Are Considered Higher Quality:

Hard enamel pins are often regarded as higher quality due to their refined appearance and superior durability. The polishing process creates a smooth, glass-like finish, giving the pins a premium look and feel. Additionally, the metal separation technique in hard enamel pins ensures clean and crisp lines between colors, resulting in a more professional and precise design. Their durability makes them ideal for long-term use, and they can withstand the rigors of being attached to bags, jackets, or other accessories without losing their original luster.


When Soft Enamel Pins Might Be a Better Choice:

While hard enamel pins offer a higher level of quality, there are instances where soft enamel pins may be more appropriate.

  • Artistic style: Soft enamel pins' textured appearance lends itself well to designs that benefit from shading and color variation. This makes them suitable for designs with intricate details, such as illustrations or logos with gradients.
  • Cost considerations: If you're working on a project with a limited budget or require a large quantity of pins, soft enamel pins are a cost-effective option. Their production process makes them more affordable while still offering visual appeal.
  • Vintage or retro aesthetics: Soft enamel pins can evoke a nostalgic feel, making them a popular choice for designs that embrace a vintage or retro style.

Understanding the differences between hard enamel pins and soft enamel pins allows you to make an informed decision when creating or purchasing enamel pins. Hard enamel pins are renowned for their smooth, polished surface, metal separation, and durability, making them the preferred choice for many collectors and enthusiasts. However, soft enamel pins have their own charm, with a textured surface and cost-effective production. Consider the desired aesthetic, budget, and overall purpose when choosing between hard enamel and soft enamel pins, and enjoy the journey of wearing or collecting these miniature works of art.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.